Straightening your smile is a huge goal for many adults, teens and parents worldwide. Not only do orthodontics make you look great, they make you able to chew your food properly, speak clearly and keep your teeth healthy in the long term. When deciding to straighten your teeth the main decision you will have to make is whether to go for traditional fixed braces or modern clear removable aligners.

Both braces and aligners work using the same scientific techniques to move your teeth into their perfect position. However, both have their own benefits, requirements, costs and expectations. We have created a complete guide to help you decide which is the right choice for your smile.

What Are Traditional Braces and How Do They Work?

Traditional braces are the most traditional type of orthodontic treatment. Small brackets are stuck onto the front of your teeth by your orthodontist using special dental glue. Thin flexible wires run through each bracket.

  • Constant Pressure – The thin wire will constantly try to return to its perfect shape. It will pull on the brackets stuck to your teeth creating constant pressure to move your teeth into the correct position.

  • Brackets – You have the choice of having either traditional metal braces or tooth colored ceramic braces. The ceramic braces will blend in with your tooth enamel.

  • Rubber Bands – Traditional braces often use small rubber bands (ligatures) to keep the wire in place. Orthodontists will also use larger elastic bands to help fix complicated bite issues.

  • Fixed – As your braces are fixed to your teeth you will never worry about losing them.

What Are Clear Aligners and How Do They Work?

Clear aligners are a modern orthodontic treatment. Rather than having metal parts, they use a series of transparent plastic trays.

  • Digital Planning – Your orthodontist will take a detailed 3D scan of your mouth. They will then plan exactly how each of your teeth will move using specialist software.

  • Plastic Trays – You will wear each set of aligners for between 1-2 weeks. Each will be slightly different to help gently push your teeth into place.

  • Attachments – Often dentists will add small bumps (attachments) made from tooth colored composite. These will give the plastic trays something to push against to help rotate and lift your teeth.

  • Removable – You can remove your aligners when eating.

Which Looks Better: Braces or Clear Aligners?

For many working professionals and teens wanting to look good, aesthetics can play a big part in deciding which treatment to have.

  • Metal Braces – These will be very visible. You will be able to see them when talking, laughing and smiling. Whilst children and teens love choosing colorful rubber bands, adults often prefer something less noticeable.

  • Ceramic Braces – These are a middle ground. They use tooth colored or transparent brackets meaning they are much less noticeable.

  • Clear Aligners – These are the most discreet option. The medical grade transparent plastic will sit against your teeth. Most people won’t realize you’re wearing them!

Which Is More Powerful: Braces or Clear Aligners?

Whilst clear aligners can fix many issues, traditional braces are much more powerful.

  • Braces – Braces are the best option for severe crowding, large overbites, severe under-bites, large gaps and rotated teeth. The fixed brackets mean orthodontists can use precise torque to move the roots of your teeth.

  • Aligners – Aligners are great for mild-moderate crowding, small gaps and simple bite issues. Although modern aligners can fix many complex cases, extremely severe jaw issues will need traditional braces.

  • Control – As the braces are fixed to each of your teeth, your orthodontist will have full control of how each tooth moves during your monthly appointments.

Which Is More Comfortable: Braces or Clear Aligners?

Both treatments will cause some discomfort as they use pressure to move your teeth. However, braces can cause more discomfort.

  • Braces – The metal and ceramic brackets have rough edges and thin wires. This can cause discomfort to the inside of your cheeks and lips. You will get mouth ulcers during the first few weeks of wearing them. You will need to use orthodontic wax to cover any sharp areas.

  • Aligners – The clear aligners have smooth edges. They rarely cause any cutting or scraping to the inside of your cheeks. You will feel some tightness and dull pressure for a day or two when changing to new trays. However, there will be little discomfort.

  • Pain After Adjustments – Braces will cause some noticeable discomfort for 2-3 days after your orthodontist has tightened your wire. Aligners distribute the pressure more evenly across all of your teeth meaning less sharp pain.

What Can You Eat and Drink With Braces or Aligners?

Depending on what treatment you choose, you will have different rules regarding food.

  • Braces – whilst wearing your braces you will not be able to eat any hard, crunchy, sticky or chewy foods. Chewing on whole apples, raw carrots, nuts, popcorn, caramel or ice can cause your brackets to snap off. This will stop your treatment and you will need to visit your emergency clinic.

  • Aligners – As your aligners are removable you can take them out before eating. You can eat all of your favorite foods.

  • Drinks – You will need to take your aligners out when drinking anything other than cold water. Hot drinks such as coffee or tea can cause the plastic to warp. Sugary or dark drinks such as fizzy drinks or red wine can get trapped inside the aligners causing them to stain.

Which Is Easier to Clean: Braces or Clear Aligners?

Keeping your teeth clean whilst having orthodontics will prevent permanent staining, white spot lesions and inflamed gums.

  • Braces – Cleaning around your braces can be time consuming. Food can easily get stuck around the metal. You will need to use special floss threaders, water flossers and tiny proxy brushes to clean between your teeth and under the arch-wire.

  • Aligners – Aligners make your daily hygiene easy. You can simply remove your aligners and clean your natural teeth.

You will need to clean your aligners daily using a soft toothbrush, mild soap or special crystals. You will also need to clean your natural teeth after every meal before putting your aligners back in.

How Much Responsibility Do Clear Aligners Require?

With the removability of clear aligners, you will have a lot of responsibility.

  • 22 Hours a Day – The aligners will only move your teeth whilst in your mouth. You will need to wear them for 20-22 hours a day. Only remove them to eat.

  • Poor Compliance – If you are regularly removing your trays for hours, losing your case or forgetting to wear them at night your teeth will stop moving. The next set of trays will not fit and your orthodontist will have to stop your treatment and order a full set of mid course correction trays.

  • Braces – Braces will work constantly throughout the day. You don’t have to rely on your will power. If you are a teen or adult who know you won’t be disciplined enough to manage your removable trays then braces will be a good option for you.

How Long Does Treatment Take With Braces or Clear Aligners?

The amount of time your treatment will take will depend on how much your teeth need to move. However, the total time and appointments will vary.

  • Braces – Traditional braces will take between 12-24 months. Complex jaw bite corrections can take up to 30 months. You will have appointments every 4-6 weeks.

  • Aligners – Aligners often take less time to complete. Mild-moderate cases can take between 6-18 months. As your trays are planned in advance using digital software you will receive multiple trays. You will have appointments every 6-10 weeks.

  • Less Emergencies – You rarely will need to attend any emergencies as there are no sharp wires to poke your cheeks or brackets to break.

Which Costs More: Braces or Clear Aligners?

Traditional braces will generally be more affordable. However, clear aligners will be a larger investment.

  • Braces – Metal braces are the cheapest option for getting your teeth fully aligned. Ceramic braces will be slightly more expensive.

  • Aligners – Aligners will be a higher price due to the 3D scanning, specialized software and high precision plastic trays. The cost will depend on how many sets of trays you need.

Many dental insurances will cover orthodontic treatments for both braces and aligners up to your maximum benefit. Most dental practices will also offer interest free monthly payments.

Why Is Retention Important After Braces or Clear Aligners?

Finishing your active orthodontic treatment is a huge achievement! However, you will need to wear retainers for life to keep your new straight smile.

Teeth have a memory. Once you have your appliance removed the bone and elastic fibers around your tooth roots will try to pull your teeth back into their crooked position.

– Retainers – Once your treatment is completed your orthodontist will fit you with custom made retainers. You can choose clear plastic retainers, traditional wire retainers or a fixed retainer wire stuck behind your front teeth.

Wear your custom retainer every night to keep your beautiful smile.

Which Should You Choose: Traditional Braces or Clear Aligners?

When Should You Choose Traditional Braces?

  • Traditional Braces – If you have severe crowding, large bite issues or complex jaw issues.

  • Traditional Braces – If you want a fixed appliance that will work automatically.

  • Traditional Braces – If you want the most affordable option.

When Should You Choose Clear Aligners?

  • Clear Aligners – If you want something discreet.

  • Clear Aligners – If you want to eat all of your favorite crunchy foods.

  • Clear Aligners – If you want to brush and floss easily.

  • Clear Aligners – If you are disciplined enough to wear your plastic trays for 22 hours a day.

Book a full diagnostic appointment with a certified orthodontist. They will take 3D scans of your teeth.

What Are the Frequently Asked Questions About Braces and Clear Aligners?

Are Clear Aligners as Effective as Traditional Metal Braces?

Yes! They are as effective as traditional braces for mild-moderate crowding, spacing and simple bite corrections. However, traditional fixed braces are more effective for severe jaw issues, extreme rotations and complex extractions.

Are Clear Aligners Less Painful Than Braces?

Generally clear aligners will cause less discomfort as they have smooth plastic edges and no brackets or wires. Both will cause some mild pressure and tightness for a couple of days however aligners distribute the pressure more evenly.

What If I Lose One of My Clear Aligners?

Contact your orthodontist straight away. They may ask you to go back to your previous set of trays or move onto your next set depending on how long you wore your lost tray. Never miss out on any trays without your doctors permission.

Can I Change From Traditional Braces to Clear Aligners?

In many cases yes. Some patients will start with traditional braces to quickly fix complex root movements and then move onto clear aligners to complete the small amount of leveling and alignment comfortably. Speak to your orthodontist to see if this would work for you.

Overall, you will need to consider your orthodontic needs, lifestyle and budget. Traditional braces will give you a reliable and powerful option to fix even the most complex dental issues. Clear aligners will give you something discreet, removable and comfortable for a busy lifestyle. Book an appointment with your orthodontist to take 3D digital scans and find out what is best for you.